新概念三 lesson 12 life on a desert island中的一个问题.

来源：学生作业帮编辑：作业帮分类：英语作业时间：2024/05/25 17:29:18

新概念三 lesson 12 life on a desert island中的一个问题.
第一大段的最后一句：
Perhaps there is an elements of truth in both these pitcure,but few of us have had to find out.
1、have had 在这里怎么理解,为什么要用have had 而不是直接用have?
2、课文翻译是：这两种想像都有可信处,但很少有人能有机会去弄个究竟.
那么按照 have had的直接翻译是不是：……,但是有极少部分的人曾经（对孤岛生存）有过这样的体会.
有些驽钝……还望赐教
打错了好多……修改下句子。
Perhaps there is an element of truth in both these pictures,but few of us have had the oppertunity to find out.

原句是Perhaps there is an element of truth in both these pictures,but few us have had the opportunity to find out.
现在完成时,过去的工作延续到现在.你的理解没问题,我帮你完善一下,时间不光是曾经,而是延续到现在.如果是曾经的话相应的时态应该用had had过去完成时了.
供参考
再问：如果只用一个have怎么样？就是表达: ……，有少部分人经历过。文法没错吧？作者就是想表达：到现在为止，有极少数人（有过这样经历），所以才用 have had 是这个意思吧？
再答：对，可以这么用。是这样的意思。就是2个have用法不同，后面的have是实意动词，“有”，前面的have是用于表示时态的

新概念三里life on a desert island里有一句they were taking a badly dam Life on a desert island is wretched. life on a desert island是什么意思 I can’t imagine ______ alone on a desert island. If____alone on a desert island,what would you do?A.leaving y 2. Imagine __ on a desert island. A . you B. yourself C. you "a desert island"中“ desert”是名词还是形容词? 英文对话要怎么写You and 3 friends are on a desert island .Disscuss w 新概念三中的一个问题新概念三第十五课中有一句话Mum or dad,of course,provide a regula 有关新概念英语三中的一个小问题英语翻译___　terrible life people on the small island lived!A Wha 英语翻译neither of the two opposite of life on a deserted island